A California court has upheld a recommendation that attorney John Eastman should lose his law license because of his central role in President Donald Trump’s effort to subvert the 2020 election.
A three-judge “review panel” of the California State Bar Court found that Eastman’s conduct was so egregious — and his remorse so lacking — that the only remedy was to permanently prohibit him from practicing law.
Legal Consequences for John Eastman
“Eastman continues to fully deny his many unethical actions: he denies he misled the courts; he denies that he made multiple false and misleading statements … he denies that he conspired to subvert the law in order to benefit his client’s desire to remain in office after his client lost a fair and lawfully conducted election,” Judge Kearse McGill wrote in the panel’s unanimous ruling.
“He used his skills to push a false narrative in the courtroom, in the White House, and in the media. That false narrative resulted in the undermining of our country’s electoral process, reduced faith in election professionals, and lessened respect for the courts of this land,” the judges concluded.
A judge of the State Bar Court, Yvette Roland, had recommended Eastman’s disbarment last year, a ruling that immediately resulted in Eastman’s suspension from practicing law.
The “review panel” ruling backs up Roland’s conclusion. Eastman’s next step is the California Supreme Court, which has the final say over attorney discipline matters. While that’s typically the end of the line, Eastman hinted he may intend to pursue his grievances against the process in federal court.
Eastman’s Legal Strategy
“Dr. Eastman is disappointed in the Review Court’s opinion, and believes that its analysis and conclusions are not substantiated by the truth, the record, or the law,” his attorney Randall Miller said in a statement. “Dr. Eastman will seek further review of the Review Court’s decision in the California Supreme Court and, if necessary, beyond, and is highly confident of his ultimate vindication.”
Eastman, who was recruited to join Trump’s legal team in the aftermath of his defeat at the polls in the 2020 election, became an increasingly prominent figure in Trump’s orbit as his bid to reverse the results grew desperate. Eastman helped draft legal efforts to challenge the outcome in key swing states — filings that the court found were riddled with unverified, false and misleading information. And he authored Trump’s brief to the Supreme Court that served as Trump’s last-ditch legal effort to halt his defeat.
But it was after those efforts failed that Eastman’s most memorable work began. Working with other fringe figures in Trump’s orbit — after many of his campaign lawyers and Republican Party officials had told him the election was lost — Eastman helped craft a strategy to convince then-Vice President Mike Pence to block Joe Biden’s victory during the Jan. 6, 2021, count of electoral votes.
Pence resisted, despite pressure from Eastman and Trump, triggering a pro-Trump mob to riot and eventually breach the Capitol, forcing Pence and Congress to flee.
Eastman and a handful of Trump’s other attorneys have been among the few to reap consequences for their role in the 2020 election saga. Disciplinary panels in Washington, D.C., have similarly found that attorney Rudy Giuliani should be disbarred and former Justice Department lawyer Jeff Clark should be suspended from practicing law. The ruling is still under review and has not yet been implemented. Clark, Giuliani and Eastman have also been criminally charged for their roles, though the cases have been mired in pretrial disputes.
